Montblanc Porsche Pens







Disclaimer on Pricing and Valuation




The Carrera Line
In the mid 1970's the school pen 042 "Monte Rosa" (introduced in 1952) was discontinued and replaced by the Montblanc Carrera Line in various finishes (mainly orange, black and silver) with metal caps and a large stainless steel clip punctuated by six holes.


Description
Good Value
Online/Auction Values
Specialty Store Pricing
Ballpoint Pen
Multifunction Ballpoint Pen
Fineliner Pen
Pencil
Fountain Pen
Sheldon Rarity Factor: (R3***) Scarce



The Turbo
Around the mid-1970s, Montblanc began an association with Porsche for a range of entry-level pens which resulted in the Carrera line of pens. Of these, the Turbo range (launched in 1978) was the high-end. A tubular design, characteristic of the period, the Turbos were done in brushed metal or silver-plate, with an odd clip which had a large black resin ball at the end and the Montblanc star in both extremeties of the pen. The range was available in ballpoint, rollerball and fountain pen variants. The fountain pen nibs were in steel (gold nibs were also made available as an option) and could use either cartridges or an ink converter. The Turbo range lasted until around 1984. Note that the ballpoint pen was one of the last Montblanc models that used the older refill type (longer than the current version, but these can be adapted with an extender and used on the older ballpoint pens).

The Turbo Ballpoint Pen

The Rollerball

The Fountain Pen

Description
Good Value
Online/Auction Values
Specialty Store Pricing
Ballpoint Pen
€ 124
US$ 75 to € 145
Rollerball Pen
€ 54
Fountain Pen
€ 70 to € 237
US$ 195
Sheldon Rarity Factor: (R3***) Scarce





Disclaimer on Pricing and Valuation
The prices given here are the low and high average found on the international market between the years 2014 and 2017. The difference between the lowest and the highest values can be due to such factors as the state of preservation, the provenience, the reputation of the seller, and the completeness of the offer (original case, documentation, ink accessories, etc.). Every collector should be fully aware of the difference between selling prices and purchase prices, and between passion and investment.
Against the normal "market pricing", the following table provides some guidelines for the valuation and negotiation of collectible (not current) fountain pens as per their condition.

CONDITION GRADE
VALUATION
WEIGHT
REMARKS
UNUSED
200%
No signs of use, New Old Stock, boxed and fully documented, not inked ever
MINT
175%
No discernable user markings, boxed, dipped or once ink filled
EXCELLENT
100%
All parts original, slight signs of use, slight surface scratches, minor discolouration, crisp imprints, trim or body with no significant brassing, no dings, may be boxed, fully working
FINE
90%
All parts original, some signs of use, surface scratching, brassing, light discolouration, fully functional
FAIR
70%
Not all parts may be original, heavy sign of use, worn imprints, used look, may need repairs, dings/stratches, medium discolouration
POOR
50%
Not working, missing parts, cracks, strong discolouration, very visible dings
Another devaluation scale may be considered for particular typologies of damage
ISSUE / DAMAGE
VALUATION EFFECT
Nib is twisted but working
- 5%
Nib is not original
- 20%
Personal name or advertising engraved
- 10%
Small dents in metal body/cap
- 10%
Significant dents in metal body/cap
- 30%
Small scratches/cracks in resin body/cap
- 10%
Very visible scratches/cracks in resin body/cap
- 35%
Without cap or wrong cap
- 20% to - 35%
Brand missing in cap (when applicable)
- 5% to - 15%
Without clip, broken clip or wrong clip
- 15%
Piston system is leaking (when applicable)
- 5% to - 20%
Piston system is not functioning (when applicable)
- 30% to - 35%
Safety mechanism is not functioning (when applicable)
- 30% to - 45%
Lever ink system not functioning(when applicable)
- 15%
No ink sack for lever ink system (when applicable)
- 5%